Guys, does being an get girls?

Ok, heres the thing, im a junior in high school. I'm very good looking (honestly, im not lying, i get compliments from girls all the time). anyway, sure ive had my fair share of girls, but when it comes to the girls that i really want, i just cant get them. it always seems to be a result of some hole shes currently into. the saying is that finish first and now im starting to believe it. i can be an if i want to, but my parents raised me in a way to treat girls nicely and so far ive lived by that, but its just not working anymore. i fall into the "friend zone" way too much and im startin to get pissed off. What should i do?